|
By Guohui Liu
Eastland Press: $65.00; 580 pp. ISBN: 0-939616-34-3
Reviewed by Douglas Eisenstark, L.Ac., www.taiqi.com
Warm Diseases, A Clinical Guide by Guohui Liu is probably one of the
best Chinese Medicine books to be published in English. Finally we have
a book that puts it all together, theory, practice, historical
perspective, written by an experienced practitioner and teacher. Just
when you thought that Chinese Medicine simply couldn't be transmitted in
English a book like this comes along. In the same league as Steven
Clavy's Fluid Physiology and Pathology or Introduction to Meridian
Therapy by Sudo Denmei, Warm Diseases shows us how a skillful writer and
publisher can create an instant classic.
Mr. Liu has several things going for him in writing this book. First, he
is a Chinese trained practitioner who studied with his father as well at
the Chengdu University of Traditional Medicine. At Chengdu he was a
professor where he also wrote articles and books. He now lives,
teaches and practices in the United States. He is obviously comfortable
in transmitting the material needed to understand and practice the
material. Mr. Liu is fluent in the historical perspectives, which he
weaves throughout the book. Finally, either he is being overly modest
about his English skills or he had considerable help from Eastland Press
for the book reads perfectly in its use of English. China's schools like
America's have "teacher's editions" of their textbooks. Whereas many
other Chinese Medicine texts seem to be a regurgitation of texts on
subjects of which the author's have neither clinical experience nor
adequate historical perspective A Clinical Guide very much is
appropriately aimed towards the actual needs of its readership.
This book reads like that class you wished you had had in Wen Bing.
Without an adequate explanation in theory, Wen Bing theory seems to be:
"these are the symptoms, these are the formulas". Liu takes us step by
step through the process of understanding not just Wen Bing theory but
also the mechanisms of Qi in all manners of treatment in Chinese
Medicine. Probably as a result of his teaching experience, when a new
concept is introduced in the book, Dr. Liu anticipates questions and
answers them with helpful explanations and case studies. Dr. Liu
obviously is aware of the difficulties in teaching the subject matter
and overcomes them in an extremely careful and thorough manner. Theory,
etiology, differentiation and treatment methods are broken down into a
completely understandable and usable manner.
Wen Bing (and Shang Han Lun) is primarily about herbal medicine. Any herbalist
should read the book for the extensive and carefully delineated
discussions for the subtleties of the herbs and formulas. Modifications
are also carefully explained. Although often shown by their English
translation there are many comparison charts and descriptions of the
formulas. One imagines that the editors at Eastland had more than a few
discussions about how to handle the listing of formulas.
In short, I think this is the next book that students or practitioners
of Oriental Medicine should add to their library.
Same book, different reviewer |